Connect
Login
Register
Movie Database & Movie Reviews
Awards
Won 2 awards & 25 nominations
See awards details »
Users' rating: 5.8

113 votes

Ranking
This week:
-
This month:
-
All time:
-
Vote
Add your vote!
Overall:
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
Favourite
Watchlist
Not interested
About the movie
Year
2007
Runtime
1 h 56 min
Director



Every third American is obese. Check if you are too!

Starring



Main cast

Judy Marshak Silver Elms Matron
Doreen Brownstone Silver Elms Bridge Player
Samantha Weinstein Hagar - Child
Ryland Thiessen Telford - Child
Mackenzie Munro Young Charlotte




External critics' reviews

Variety Eddie Cockrell
Prolific helmer Kari Skogland draws a fiery performance from vet Burstyn and a beguiling one from Christine Horne as the young Hagar. Yet the book's sheer "Giant"-like scope necessitates generational cross-cutting that's both rushed and cluttered; pic would have have been better served as a more leisurely miniseries. more
New York Daily News Joe Neumaier
Writer-director Kari Skogland adapts a beloved Canadian novel gracefully and with plenty of spunk, the same way its main character moves through the world from cradle to grave. more
Village Voice Tim Grierson
Despite its cutesy comic-relief digressions and overdone solemnity, The Stone Angel finds its way past tonal inconsistencies to a moving conclusion that doesn't romanticize death. more
Los Angeles Times Gary Goldstein
Burstyn gets to use her full bag of tricks to bring this crabby, hard-knocks survivor to life. Though she's aged 15 unflattering years, forced into awful old lady clothes and her character teeters on unsympathetic, the actress manages a rich, vanity-free performance, perhaps her best since "Requiem for a Dream." more
The New York Times Stephen Holden
This multigenerational family history has enough gripping moments to hold your attention, but ultimately it leaves you frustrated by its failure to braid subplots and characters into a gripping narrative. more
New York Post Lou Lumenick
A lesson in the perils of trying to cram a hefty Canadian novel that spans decades into a movie running just under two hours. more


Show more external critic's reviews



Liked or not? Share your opinion below.

Comments
date added


Add comment

Pnop.Messages.TYPE.error

PNOP Rankings

 

PNOPer
See what you should watch tonight!


Sign Up or Login for more recommendations

PNOP TOP



Feedback
Copyright © 2012 PNOP.com Blog Contact us Privacy policy Terms of use Help Pnop Wars